Asha Bhosle and Lata Mangeskhkar – beyond music, the legacy of smashing the gender norms in a patriarchal film industry of the 50s and 60s

“When we were children, I was closest to Lata (Mangeshkar) didi. She used to lift me in her arms and run around the whole city with me. We were both so deeply connected that she took me with her to her class every day. Eventually one day, the teacher forbade both of us from sitting in the same class. When the teacher stopped us from staying there, we both reached home crying. And then didi ( Lata) stopped going to school without me. Baba said he would arrange a private teacher for us, and that was the end of her going to school.”

These words of singer Asha Bhosle describe the childhood relationship she shared with her sister Lata Mangeshkar.

Asha Bhosle passed away at the age of 92 on 12th April 2026. Lata Mangeshkar too had passed away at the age of 92 in 2022. In one of her earlier tweets, Lata Mangeskhar had shared a nostaglic photo of the two.

One can celebrate the journeys of Asha Bhosle and Lata Mangeshkar for their musical talent, for their success, for the money they earned, for the genius of their voices that have millions of admirers.

But beyond all this, female artists like Asha Bhosle achieved something even greater in those times—finding success in a film world that was dominated by men on all sides, an industry that was deeply patriarchal. 

Imagine the 1940s or 50s: a 16–17-year-old girl singing in a studio, year after year surrounded only by men in an era when playback singing was still in its early stages.

From music directors and lyricists to instrumentalists—mostly men. During recording, if the film director or producer came, he too was a man. Those who paid salaries, those who gave work—everyone was male.

Within this system, both sisters achieved success as female artists, achieved it on their own terms.

The single mother, the breadwinner

And think about it—at that time Asha Bhosle was a young  single working mother, a reality for which there was hardly any gender sensitivity back then.

In an interview with veteran music director Salil Chowdhury, Asha Bhosle said,

“When I started singing, I lived very far from Bombay and came daily by train to sing. In 1949, when I was 16, my child was born. I had to leave behind a one-month-old baby and go to the studios.  Every morning at 5am I used to practice, the house also had to be managed—drawing water from the village well, cooking food, taking care of mother-in-law and brother-in-law, and returning late at night after work. Later as a single mother, as the sole bread winner of the family many times, I would have to leave the studio to breastfeed my children because they were small and then return again to complete the recordings.”

In the 40s and 50s, when many women did not venture out to work, perhaps it may have never occurred to a listener or to studio owners and directors that this velvety voice, singing romantic or cabaret songs, was also fighting another battle- a battle that was for the women alone to fight.

From cabarets to Grammy nomination

Despite all the challenges, female artists like Asha Bhosle and Lata Mangeshkar did not pull back the line of success drawn by men who controlled power dynamics.

Instead, these two went so far ahead  that the line of success they drew for themselves became the industry benchmark.

In 1958, Lata protested against the lack of a playback singer category at the Filmfare Awards, refusing to sing at the event till a category was created.

Where Asha broke through the ranks to sing not just the cabarets or vamp songs but also award winning ghazals and devotional songs and earned Grammy nominations.

This could not have been easy, because people constantly called Asha Bhosle ,Lata Mangeshkar’s competitor.

When the film Saaz was released in 1998, it told the story of two sisters whose father was a singer and who themselves took up singing as a career—very similar to the story of Lata and Asha Bhosle. The film showed that the sisters loved each other deeply, but when it came to their careers, a wall stood between them.

The younger sister says: we will always keep our professional matters and personal love separate. The world of music is large enough for both of us.

But the elder sister says: there is only space for one person at the top.

Although the film’s story takes many turns, and the director also said that the film had nothing to do with Lata and Asha Bhosle, the speculation never ended.

The duets sung by Asha and Lata

“Look, in childhood the younger sister imitates the elder sister; it happens in every household. At that time, the way Didi (Lata) sang, I sang the same way. The way she moved her mouth, I did the same. But then I saw that Lata’s name had become so big in films—so who would give songs to those who sang like her? That singer would have no place of her own. People would say: she sings like her sister, but she is not Lata. I wanted to know who I was. My singing had to be mine.”

Asha and Lata both have innumerable solo hits to their name. However, to celebrate the lives of both, it becomes essential to remember the songs that Asha and Lata sang together—gifts for lovers of Hindi film music. For example:

  1. The song Man kyon mehka re mehka aadhi raat ko from the 1985 film Utsav, which people perhaps remember the most. I like listening to this song more than watching it.
  2. R.D. Burman had two favorite singers—Lata Mangeshkar and Asha Bhosle. In the 1981 film Jail Yatra, he had both of them sing Pake akele mohe.
  3. Or the song from the film Haar Jeet—
    Tu badi kismat wali hai, tere aanchal mein sab kuch hai, mera aanchal khaali hai

Or the 1964 film Jahan Ara song— Jab jab tumhein bhulaya tum aur yaad aaye which features both sisters’ voices. This is perhaps my most favorite among the songs they sang together.

There is a song from the 1969 Hindi film Prince— Muqabla humse na karo, hum tumhein apne rang mein rang daalenge ek hi pal mein ( Don’t compete with us, we will colour you in our hue )

In this song, the magic created on screen by Vyjayanthimala and Helen through their dance is matched by voices of Lata Mangeshkar and Asha Bhosle behind the screen.

When Hasrat Jaipuri wrote the lyrics of this song, he probably never imagined how perfectly these in lines would fit the journeys of Asha Bhosle and Lata Mangeshkar—because these two truly challenged the world, fought the system, and coloured everyone in their own hue:

Hamare saamne kis ka chiraag jalta hai,
hamare saamne sooraj bhi haath malta hai
Muqabla humse na karo, hum tumhein apne rang mein rang daalenge ek hi pal mein

Mannu Bhandari: The feminist gaze behind Rajnigandha, Aapka Bunti and Trishanku

When I had seen the film Rajnigandha for the first time on Doordarshan, it kind of blew me away. We were normally not used to such narratives, a story of an independent woman on screen, told by a woman, through the gaze of a woman.

The woman who chooses a man of her choice, a man who sometimes is not as caring and thoughtful as she wants him to be but they love each other nonetheless. One fine day, she comes across her ex-lover who showers all the attention on her she has craved for.

It brings back memories of old times when they were together. And now she wonders whom does she love actually? And whom should she choose. There are no moral judgements here. The song Kayi bar yun bhi dekha hai, Ye Jo Man ki seema rekha hai, man todne lagta hai.. captures the essence of her writing in some way.

It was only later I came to know that it is based on the story by writer Mannu Bhandari Yahi Sach Hai. If there is a way of defining feminist writing, this was it.  It is such a simple yet powerful story.

A Feminist writer

Mannu Bhandari is celebrating her 90th birthday. Born as Mahendra Kumari on 3 April 1931 in Madhya Pradesh, Bhanpura, Mannu Bhandari’s pen has given expression to so many tales of modern women- yearning to break away from the shackles of society in post-independence India. 

Just as India was finding its way through after independence,  Mannu Bhandari’s stories and books parallely chart the journey of women in that era and the churning s and changes in society.Or one can see her writings as a comment on interpersonal relationships and its contradictions.

‘Maine zindgi ko nangi aankhon se dekha’

Her story Trishanku, is admittedly one of her own favourites based on an incident from her own life which she had recounted in an interview posted on you tube by Hindi Urdu Flagship.

She says, “My daughter was in 9th standard and some young college boys used to tease her, chhedte the usko. So I thought why don’t I invite those boys to my house and make friends with them and see how it makes me feel? Will I be able to accept this? It was like an experiment on myself that I consider myself modern but am I really?”

I wonder how would have this thought even crossed her mind at that time.  I love her lines when she had said, “Maine zindgi ko nangi aankhon se dekha, jo mehsus kiya usko ho apni kahaniyon mein abhivyakti di.”

The mental duel between the daughter and mother is really fascinating in Trishanku- specially the mother who sometimes is so open minded and supports the daughter and sometimes she sticks to old conservative values, making it difficult for the daughter to decipher her.  

Hence the title Trishanku who is a mythological character who hangs between heaven and hell.  Her daughter Rachna Yadav had given a kathak presentation based on this story.

The Rajani fame

Apart from stories and novels, Swami, Darpan and Nirmala –these are some of the films she wrote for.  She wrote for some episodes of the famous TV serial Rajani which created this image of a no-nonsense housewife who would make it sure that no issue goes unaddressed be it cheating in LPG cylinders, school admissions, corruption.   

Mannu Bhandari had famously recalled how the grocery stores near her house would make sure that every item is weighed properly, kyonki wo Rajani wali madam hai !

Mannu Bhandari’s screenplay for an episode of Rajani was even made part of NCERT and can be found here.

Ek Kahani Ye Bhi

Mannu Bhandari also came with her life story in the form of Ek Kahani Ye Bhi which started as an essay but eventually became a repository of her life.

She was married to writer Rajendra Yadav and the two separated. He had also come up with a semi-autobiographical book which touched upon their relationship and later in response to this, Mannu wrote her own version why she decided to separate from him.

Coming back to her literature, Mannu Bhandari has been writing since the 1950s and a seminal work by Mannu Bhandari is Aapka Bunti-a novel through the eyes of a kid Bunti whose parents are getting divorced. But one doesn’t know if actually the story of Bunti or the mother who is struggling to make space for her ambitions in the marriage.

Ek inch Muskhan was quite an experimental novel which was a collectively written with Rajendra Yadav,. (Before that, Gyarah sapnon ka desh was written collectively by 10 writers but it wasn’t a success.)

Mahabhoj is considered another classic with its critical eye on the bureaucracy and caste system. 

Tale of conflicts woven into stories

There is a recent interview with Mannu Bhandari available on Cineink with Achala Sharma done in 2019 where she shares that her only regret is that she couldn’t write more due to ill health.

She suffered from Neuroglia which took her writing years away.

Apka Bunti was later turned into film Samay  ki Dhara which also lead to a court case. It starred starring Shatrughan Sinha, Shabana Azmi, Shreeram Lagoo, Tina Munim and Vinod Mehra.

In an era, when there were fewer women writers, it is remarkable to have writers like Mannu Bhandari and Krishna Sobti.

And for me, the biggest takeaway has been the way she etched women characters- some fighting and challenging the society till the end for their dreams and some falling to the system and their dreams buried permanently in the deepest recesses of their heart.

You can listen to an earlier interview with Mannu Bhandari from 2011 here with BBC Hindi by Samiratamaj Misra.

( Mannu Bhandari turned 90 on 3rd April 2021)

Sholay, Deewar, Silsila: Diwakar Karkare- the vintage poster man of Bollywood no more

The heroes , the villains, the heroines – you see them all in full glory in the film posters. Hand made posters created with much love, creativity and labour. Atleast in the bygone era.

Yet in film world, there is hardly any mention of these great poster artists who have actually helped made many a career.

One of the top and legendary Poster artists of Bollywood, Diwakar Karkare passed away on 5th Jan at the age of 81 years.

Sholay, Suhaag, Don, Naseeb, Kabhie Kabhie,The Burning Train.. you name it and he created these wonders.

There was a time when there was no 24 by 7 media and the poster of the film in itself was one of the most potent mediums of promotion. The image of a hero could be made or unmade by a poster.

This is what Diwakar Karkare was capable of.

A student of the JJ School of Art , Diwakar Karkar was the king of poster art in the 60s and ruled till the late 80s.

Those beautiful strokes in Silsila evoked the romance, the passion, the unfulfilled love stories..with all characters merging into one another.

And the poster of Yash Chopra’s Kaala Patthar conveys the angst and the dark world of its characters.

In Don, the thrill, the energy, the chase of its character ( Bachchan on the run) is cooly conveyed in the poster. And of the iconic Sholay which is considered the milestone film of Hindi cinema

Amongst all the people who created the angry young man persona for Amitabh Bachchan, one of them was Diwarkar Karmakar with this posters.

One of the best posters for me is for Ramanand Sagar’s Aankhein. If you see A and E alphabets, you can see the eyes ( aakhein). Also, the way some of the letters like k and h are placed extending upwards and placed through the eyes of Mala Sinha and Dharmendra.

And how can one forget Gulzar’s Koshish about the deaf and mute couple. The poster so beautifully portrays the myriad emotions and leaves you imagining for more.

Similarly the Poster for Basu Chatterjee’s film Swami speaks for itself.

Waqt from 1965 with Yash  Chopra, Johny Mera Naam by Vijay Anand, Satyam Shivam Sundram with Raj Kapoor, Benazir with Bimal Roy were amongst his art work.

His speciality was considered to be a technique involving palette knives.

He created his own studio called Studio Diwakar

The digital age almost marked the end of this art of poster making. And artists like Diwakar Karkare were almost forgotten. But he continues to live on. Like on the wall of my room in this poster bought from the bylanes of Delhi.

(All posters created by Diwakar Karmakar)

Migrant Tales via Films, From Do Bigha Zamin to Gaman: 2020

Never before in my living memory, the world has been so united in grief and That’s what the year 2020 will leave behind.  Tales of personal loss, grief that can’t be expressed in words.

If there’s one thing or incident that really impacted me to the core this year was the sight of thousands of migrants in India walking barefoot in searing heat back to their villages during Lockdown.

It was the images of these migrant labourers that made me take refuge in a medium I relate to the most – Films and I started chronicling how Hindi films have looked at migrants , their dreams, their hearbreak, their aspirations .

Here is compilation of five Hindi films each looking at the story of a migrant and their untold journeys

Do Bigha Zameen (1953): It is the story of a farmer and his family in the village who ultimately become unemployed migrants in city having failed to save their land from moneylenders. Shambu ( Balraj Sahni) sells everything to pay off the 65 rupee loan due to the local landlord.But as is with Sahukars and seths, the loan is made to be 235 rupees 8 aana in the court.

https://lovelifeandcinema.wordpress.com/2020/06/14/do-bigha-zamin-the-story-of-peasant-migrants-brought-alive-by-balraj-sahni-and-bimal-roy/

Disha: The Om Puri- Nana Patekar 1990 film is about inner conflicts of a city migrant no one ever notices when they are forced to live in pitiable conditions leaving the families behind in villages.

https://lovelifeandcinema.wordpress.com/2020/05/16/migrants-disha-conflict-of-a-displaced-life-by-sai-paranjpye-2/

FAROOQ SHEIKH

Gaman (1978) : The story of longing, of never being able to return to village homes, the story of a migrant stuck in a city that hardly cares. Farooq Sheikh and Smita Patil give a heartbreaking performance as the separated couple. The migrant is simply a faceless number in the city.

https://lovelifeandcinema.wordpress.com/2020/05/31/gaman-the-story-of-departure-of-migrants-whom-farooq-and-smita-patil-bring-to-life-3/

Paar (1984): The Naseeruddin Shah-Shabana Azmi film is about Caste, displacement and life of a helpless migrant couple from a woman’s gaze. If desperation, pain and heartbreak had a face, it would be the faces of Naurangia and Rama. The depiction of a lower class migrant in the city can’t be more real than this.

https://lovelifeandcinema.wordpress.com/2020/05/23/migrants-naseer-shabana-film-paar-on-crossing-over-to-the-other-side/

Shree 420: This 1955 Raj Kapoor film is thet tale of the the educated, unemployed migrant and clash of morality. Written by Khwaja Ahmed Abbas, the film moves from the story of a migrant to a tale of morality and criminality or char sau beesi as the title suggests Shree 420. In newly independent India, the film was a comment on unemployment, lack of housing and forced migration from rural to urban areas.

https://lovelifeandcinema.wordpress.com/2020/06/18/shree-420-raj-the-migrant-and-a-tale-of-morality/

Made in India and Titan : Never had a watch growing up yet everything was on time.

So many people have loved the web series Made in India: A Titan Story directed by  Robbie Grewal.

I really liked it too. In fact, I made an exception to watch it, because I had almost stopped watching Indian web series.  Grew tired of the gore, violence, abuse, and endless gaali-galauj. The acting, of course ,by Jim Sarbh and Naseeruddin Shah , in Titan was top-notch.

And everyone seems to have a Titan watch story to tell. People have been sharing lovely pictures and memories of their Titan watches. That says a lot about why the brand became so successful.

And then I realised – I have no Titan story to tell.

Because I have never bought a watch in my entire life.

The one beautiful watch I do have was gifted to me by my lovely team.

Never bought a watch in my life

I never wore a watch in my growing-up years, in college, at university, or later in my job – ever.

And I started wondering why.

As a child, I was around my mother most of the time, and somehow she never wore a watch either.

Despite the fact that her life ran like clockwork – waking at 4 am, making breakfast and lunch for everyone, getting the kids ready for school, getting herself ready, and leaving by 7:30 am for her school, which was on a steep hill in a nearby village.

Because I never saw her wearing a watch, maybe it never caught my fancy. Also with the limited means, a watch was never really a top priority in the early days.

But there was another big reason too.

We lived in a small, semi-hilly town in the lap of nature, where everything had its own time and rhythm. And that rhythm was enough for us to know what time of day it was.

We never really needed a clock or a watch for that.

Early in the morning, around 4 or 5 am, the sounds from the local gurudwara and mandir would begin. Both stood side by side. For some it was a divine start , for some it did come as a bit of disturbance.

But the most beautiful sound in the morning was the birds. They were everywhere, in abundance near our house due to the greenery.

Their chirping told you it was time to wake up. And with the Shivalik mountains visible from the window, the rising sun, and birdsong in the air – who needed a watch?

At 7 am sharp, the horn of the local train that took employees from the township to Bhakra Dam would sound. That was our 7 o’clock signal.

Then at 7:30 am, the town hooter would go off. It meant the workshop shift had begun.

The only Auntyji in our block who drove a scooter would be outside by then, kicking it hard to get it started. That too meant it was time for school.

If I was home and there was no school that day, I would study or sit for hours in our super-sized, meticulously maintained garden.

By afternoon, the shadows of the trees would begin to shift, everything would go quieter, and you just knew it was lunchtime.

At 4:30 pm, the town hooter would go off again. No need to look at a clock.

Also, the bus from Bhakra Dam carrying employees would stop on the main road around then.

The bus had a particular sound. Sitting in the garden, you knew without looking that the bus had arrived – and that Papa would be home soon. It was also a signal to be alert and switch off the TV if we kids had been watching it. Hehe.

At 5 pm, the train from the Dam would sound its horn again, and hordes of people would return carrying their tiffins.

Soon after, flocks of birds would begin gathering in formations across the sky – a sight I can never forget. It signalled evening, and it was time to gather up books, finish homework  and pack up things from the garden.

The birds were like an instant signal for all children to drop everything and run to the common ground for playtime. A silent ground would suddenly come alive with shouting, laughing, rambling kids – the most thriving place on earth.

Later, the whistles of pressure cookers would begin competing with our excited screams. Dinner would be ready, and unwilling children would be hauled back home for dinner.

The unmistakable click of the TV shutter for the Doordarshan news meant it was 8:40 pm. And after the news, everything shut down. That meant it was around 9 pm. Everyone would go to sleep – except the mothers, I think.

And just like that, the day would be over and night would take over. That sharp humming sound of the jhingur was like the nighttime lullaby.  One would go to sleep listening to that humming sound , sometimes broken by the sudden hum of the refrigerator .

There was no time, and no need, to look at a watch or clock. Everything worked really well. I was never late. There was an inherent sense of time inculcated due to this unique upbringing. Till today, I am my own alarm clock.

Even today, a watch still feels like an alien thing to me – except for the precious one I keep in my drawer, gifted by my lovely team.

But thank you, JRD Tata and Xerxes Desai, for giving Indians – and the world – the Titan watch.

Thank you, Xerxes Desai, for dreaming big, for not giving up, for making mistakes, for saying sorry, and for fighting every bit for yourself and your employees. And thank you, JRD Tata, for the mentorship and trust.

The world got a world-class watch.

I grew up telling time by birdsong, train horns, shadows, hooters, pressure cookers, and Doordarshan.


Maybe that is why I never wore one.


Nature was our watch.
And the rhythm of the small town was enough to tell the time.

Series – Made in India: A Titan Story

Directed by- Robbie Grewal

Written by- Kandarp Shroff, Karan Vyas, Niraj Dasa

Yash Chopra’s Kabhie Kabhie: Amitabh Bachchan and the Fragility of Romantic Masculinity

The beautiful valleys of Kashmir, poetry drenched in love, the ache of broken relationships, the shadow of the past over present bonds, and the struggle of not being able to move beyond that past…

In February 1976, 50 years ago, when Yash Chopra’s film Kabhie Kabhie was released, it felt like a delicate velvet sheet of emotions. ( all images credit – Kabhie Kabhie/Yash Raj)

Confronting the past and gender dyanimcs

Kabhie Kabhie is essentially the story of several characters who, for one reason or another, remain entangled in their past.

Is sacrificing one’s love for the sake of family not an injustice to emotions? Can one truly move forward after leaving behind relationships lived with such intensity?

Do women cope with the past better than men? Can one’s perspective toward the past ever change?

Kabhie Kabhie compels one to think about these questions.

Raakhee, Amitabh, Neetu — characters struggling with the past

There is a scene toward the end of the film featuring Shashi Kapoor’s character.

Unaware of his wife Raakhee’s past relationship with Amitabh, he himself is a fan of the poet Amit (Amitabh).

On his wedding night, he asks Raakhee to recite the very nazm that Amitabh had once written for her.

Years later, one evening, Shashi Kapoor learns that Raakhee and Amitabh were once lovers.

For a few moments, filled with jealousy, Shashi Kapoor taunts both Raakhee and Amitabh about their relationship and says that even without being present, Amitabh was there between them on their wedding night.

But he is shown as someone who realizes his mistake.

Condemning himself, he says,

Main ek bahut chhota aadmi nikla. Mard bahut swarthi hote hain. Jo aurat tumhare bachche ki maa banti hai, jo bees saal tumhare saath is tarah rehti hai jaise sookhi, banjar zameen par baarish baras rahi ho —aur phir mard sochne lagta hai, uska maazi kya tha…kya woh kisi se mili thi…kya usne kisi se mohabbat ki thi…Main sochta hoon ki aisi chhoti aur ghatiya baatein sochkar mard khud ko gira deta hai.

( “I turned out to be a very small man. The woman who becomes the mother of your child, who spends twenty years with you like rain falling on dry barren land — and then the man begins to think about what her past was, whether she had met someone else, whether she loved someone else. I think by entertaining such petty and cheap thoughts, a man lowers himself.”)

This crucial scene becomes even more sensitive and powerful because of Shashi Kapoor’s charm and his simple yet impactful acting.

When the film could have been shelved

Despite its eventual success there was also a moment when the film’s producer had said the film should be shelved.

In an interview with Karan Johar, Yash Chopra had said,

“In a way, Kabhie Kabhie was an art film. An experiment with romance. The film was not originally conceived the way it eventually turned out. In the film, Raakhee marries Shashi Kapoor instead of Amitabh, and the song Kabhie Kabhie plays at her wedding. I had thought there would be seven wedding rounds, and with each round a scene of Amitabh and Raakhee’s love would be shown — imagined by Amitabh.

But one day the producer Gulshan Rai invited me to dinner and clearly said this film will not work. Everything about it is going against it.”

“Gulshan Rai said that in Kabhie Kabhie Amitabh has a moustache. He is the father of two daughters. Whereas people have just seen him in Deewaar. Gulshan Rai said forget this film. But my film’s recordist Mangesh Desai reassured me that this film would work — just don’t begin it in such an artistic way. Start it directly.

The film was a huge success.

Is it one of Yash Chopra’s finest films?

The story, written by Pamela Chopra and woven into a screenplay by Sagar Sarhadi, connects all the characters’ threads to one another.

 Amitabh’s character is shown living with his wife (Waheeda Rehman), but even after twenty years he can never separate himself from his past. His bungalow is even named “Ateet” (Past).

Waheeda Rehman too has a hidden past -where she a daughter before her marriage to Amitabh. She gives her daughter up for adoption and dedicates her entire life to her husband.

But Amitabh Bachchan can never do the same. When Waheeda decides to finally leave the house, the man who always lived in the past can only say,

“If you want to go, it’s your wish. You will not receive forgiveness.”

There is no hero here, no villain. Can it be counted among Yash Chopra’s finest films? I would rate Deewar as of his best- screenplay, the story arch, the interplay of emotions and the climax.

The magic of Sahir, Mukesh and Khayyam

Beyond screenplay, acting, and direction, what has kept Kabhie Kabhie alive even today are its songs, music, and singing — lyrics by Sahir Ludhianvi and music by Khayyam, rendered in the voices of Lata Mangeshkar and Mukesh.

Amid the overflowing emotions of the characters, the beauty and serenity of Kashmir also become a character in the film.

Kabhie Kabhie was very successful at the box office. But the famous song sung by Mukesh — Main Pal Do Pal Ka Shayar Hoon — teaches a different philosophy: that name, wealth, and fame slip through the hands like sand, that everything in life is temporary.

And as Amitabh says at the end of the film — in life, today is everything. What has passed, has passed.

Chitchor: A simple tale of love and the right of a woman to say no by Basu Chatterjee

There are grand, aesthetic, picturesque, action and dialogue heavy movies and then there is Chitchor.

It can’t get simpler, seamless and graceful than this. 

The 1976 Rajshri Productions movie Chitchor by Basu Chatterjee is like that gentle breeze on a summery evening that sooths your mind. And the music of the film soothes your soul. 

There are no menacing villains, no larger-than-life heroism- just everyday relatable characters in the fictional village of Madhupur.

It’s 50 years to this heart stealer of a movie aptly called Chitchor.  Amol Palekar with his trademark boy next door and the earthy Zarina Wahab hardly seem to be the stars- they look lived real-life people living amongst us. And that bundle of cuteness Master Raju as the child actor.

Matlab in that film, Akhi film cast ek taraf aur Master Raju ek taraf.

To abhi kya mere bhag band hain?

 Based on a Bengali story by Subodh Ghosh, Chittachakor, on the surface, it is a simple romantic comedy but in essence, it is the story of a woman’s right to say NO.

In nutshell, Geeta (Zarina Wahab) lives in her village with her parents – the school headmaster (AK Hangal) and mother (Deena Pathak). The main aim of the mother is to get Geeta married who has just finished her 10th exams. 

Reflecting the mindset of that era and the situation, when a suitable match is proposed for Geeta ( Zarina), the mother says, Tere Bhaga khul jayenge.

Geeta is not loud or fiery or assertive, but she questions – To abhi kya mere bhag band hain? Main abhi padhungi, BA, MA, LLB Karungi.

Geeta’s constant companion is the neighbourhood school going boy Deepu. Though we hardly see him going to school.  Geeta and Deepu are mostly seen goofing around in the village, playing marbles, gulels and running after butterflies.

Love over sunset walks and music 

When the suitable boy (Amol Palekar) lands in the village, the parents encourage Geeta to meet him on one pretext or the other so that Amol Palekar starts liking her. But Geeta asks, Maan lo main unhe pasand na karun to?

Clearly the almost schoolgirlish Geeta is hardly interested in Amol Palekar who is into classical music and philosophy. 

Imagine this conversation between the two when Geeta comes to meet Amol Palekar who is immersed in music. He passionately explains,

  Main raag malkauns ga raha tha. Ab Yaman kalyan ko lo. Shaam ke waqt jab suraj dhalne lagta hai , asman neele se narangi rang ka ho jata hai charo taraf shant watawawn chha jata hai , panchiyon ke jhund apne apne ghar wapas laute hain .insaan bhi din bhar ke kaam ke baad halke man se wapas lauta hai , us waqt man ki jo sthithi hoti hai, use ye rag jis bakhoobi se padakta hai …daba hua aaroh , teevra shudh madhyam.

None of this makes sense to Geeta or Deepu who are bored and make it clear in so many words. 

But gradually, over flowers, sunset walks, jeep safaris and music classes, they both start falling for each other.  And Geeta (Zarina) also learns to sing.

When Zarina dares to walk out 

Some of the most soulful songs by Yesudas and Hemlata are the soul of this film.   Gori Teri Gaon Bada Pyara reflects the rustic beauty of the village and Zarina Wahab.  

Jab shaam dhale aana is a beautiful ode to the blossoming love. 

However, the big twist comes when everyone realises that the Amol Palekar is not the suitable boy, but it is a case of mistaken identity. It is actually his boss, a suave Germany returned Vijendra Ghatge, who is the real suitor who now lands in the village. 

The same process follows. Geeta is encouraged to meet the new suitor so that he begins to like her. But both Deepu and Geeta have given their hearts to Amol Palekar.  Though Deepu has another motive, he is obessed with Amol Palekar’s Jeep too.

Meanwhile, the parents decide that it is Vijendra Ghatge with whom Zarina Wahab will be engaged to. 

And Amol Palekar leaves without even a pretence of fight- the good sincere boy that he is. 

On the day of engagement, Zarina Wahab gets ready and takes his most trustworthy companion Deepu and declares and leaves for the railway station to stop Amol Palekar from going. 

Main koi khilona nahin, jo jaise chahe mujhse khele ..Jo hona tha ho chuka.

Ultimately, it is not love but this simple yet strong willed girl’s determination and self awareness of her rights that wins .

The magic of Yesudas, Hemalata and Ravindra Jain

The beauty of the film lies in the simple yet tender moments,  the stolen glances, the village setting, the subtle humour and the melodious music.

It was perhaps for the first time that most Hindi Film music lovers heard Yesudas in a Hindi film.  Be it Tu jo mere sur mein or Aaj se Pehle, each song written and composed by Ravindra Jain is a treat.

And a special word for the cinematography by KK Mahajan. Despite not shooting in some picturesque locales, each frame is so aesthetic., especially the way sun has been captured. There are frames I watch repeatedly just to watch sun in its glory.

I wish I could visit that bungalow in Panchgani where Gora tera goan was filmed.

National Awards

Yesudas –   Best playback singer  – Gori Tera Gaon

Master Raju-Best child actor 

Filmfare Awards 

Hemlata- Best playback singer – Tu jo mere sur mein 

Arijit Singh: Why do people quit at the top?

Fame, wealth, respect, love, the peak of one’s career… people spend months, years, decades chasing all of this.

So, what happens that someone, after reaching this peak, suddenly finds the courage, desire, and self-control to give it all up?

Arijit Singh is currently one of the most popular and successful singers in Hindi cinema. Every year his songs top the charts, his concerts stay packed. Yet, at this peak, at 38 years, he bid farewell to playback singing—permanently.

AR Rehman sums him up in his recent BBC Interview, “He is a great musician, He is reckless and works from his village, which is very cool.” 

You can see strands of this trait in Arijit’s latest decision.

Vinod Khanna and Sanyas

Though he’s not the first to do so. In Hindi cinema itself, one of the biggest stars of the 1970s, Vinod Khanna shocked everyone in 1982 when he renounced the world and left films. At the time, Vinod Khanna had started appearing on film sets dressed in saffron robes and wearing a mala.

Suddenly, Vinod Khanna called a press conference with his family in Mumbai—a rare move in those days.

He stunned everyone by announcing that he was leaving films. Vinod left India and went to America to become a disciple of Osho.

On Simi Garewal’s TV show, he explained why he went to Osho:

“I used to get angry at everything. I had reached a saturation point. I wanted to become the master of my own mind.”

Nearly five years later, Vinod Khanna returned to India and resumed acting.

Fame vs  Reset button

Child star Zaira Wasim, who became famous with Dangal, also made headlines when she suddenly announced in 2019 that she was quitting everything.

Zaira had gained immense success from Dangal and Secret Superstar. She had even won the National Film Award for Best Supporting Actress for Dangal.

If you look at each case, everyone had their own reasons for making decisions like this—health, religion, spirituality, or simply making space for newer people.

Or an inner urge to do something completely different leads them to such decisions.

National Award–winning actor Vikrant Massey also shocked many when, in December 2014, he announced he would take a long break.


His statement hinted at the urge of wanting to steal some time for oneself and for loved ones. Vikrant had said,

“The last few years have been good, but as I keep moving forward, I realize it’s time for me to reset and go back home—as a husband, father, son, and also as an actor. So, in 2025 we will meet one last time. Until the time feels right again.”

Zaira Wasim- I drifted away from my faith

Zaira Wasim’s reason, however, was completely different—deeply rooted in faith and spirituality.

When she left films, she said:

“This field gave me love, support, and praise, but it also led me astray. Silently and unknowingly, I drifted away from my faith. I found peace and comfort in the divine knowledge of the Quran. When I had lost my way, only He guided me back. I officially announce my departure from this field.”

On the path to success, where there is glamour and abundance of money, it also demands relentless work. As a public figure, success brings instant applause, but failure brings sharp taunts, criticism, and social media trolling.

When Aamir Khan decided to quit

In this world of fame, everything becomes public, the boundaries of privacy shrink. Life is scrutinized under a magnifying glass. A hero of one day can become a zero the next.

In the rush relationships too get entangled in the web of success. Perhaps that is why Aamir Khan quietly decided to quit acting during the Covid period.

He has shared in interviews, “I had told my family that I was done with films and acting I only wanted to be with my family. But my decision did not make headlines because hardly any films were being made during Covid. My children convinced me to return.”

Hollywood – ‘Desire to not be seen by the public anymore’

Hollywood has seen such examples too. In 2025, Hollywood actress Cate Blanchett said she wanted to quit acting and do something else.

Sean Connery, known for James Bond, also retired in 2005 though after a long career. His statement made waves when he said, “I am fed up with the idiots. The gap between those who know how to make films and those who greenlight them is widening.”

Three-time Oscar winner Jack Nicholson has not worked since 2010. He used to say that his desire to not be seen by the public anymore drew him away from films.

To leave everything after achieving everything must require courage.

Perhaps that’s why actor Neena Gupta has termed it as a courageous decision.  Or as Sanjay Mishra has said, “It is good for an artist to take a break sometimes.”

Such decisions may feel shocking, but perhaps they can be understood through the words of Hollywood’s silent-era superstar Greta Garbo, who retired in 1941 at the age of 36, saying only: “I want to be left alone. That’s all.”

Shakti Samanta @100:  The director who gave Rajesh Khanna,  Shammi Kapoor and Sharmila Tagore their biggest hits

The film industry never tires of celebrating the aura of Rajesh Khanna-the superstar who sent fans into frenzy.  Or the charisma and flamboyance of Shammi Kapoor.

Today, is the time to talk about the director who shaped and sharpened the careers of several stars including Rajesh Khanna – Shakti Samanta.

2026 marks 100 years of producer-director Shakti Samanta.

It was the 1969 Shakti Samanta film Aradhana that put Rajesh Khanna on the way to superstardom along with Sharmila Tagore- a pair that was to become audiences’ favourite. 

Rajesh Khanna-Shakti Samant combination

Aradhana- a mainstream film that dared to put Sharmila Tagore in her hey days in the role of an old mother and a younger version.  And he had the conviction of taking a newcomer in one of his big films.

In contrast, he had Sharmila Tagore in An evening in Paris, in a bikini, not a norm in those days.

In many of his films, especially with Rajesh Khanna, women were at the forefront of the narrative – be it Kati Patang, Amar Prem or Aradhana.

Kati Patang to Amar Prem

From the suspense story of a young girl forced to live as a widow in Kati Patang ( Asha Parekh),  to the story of a young blind girl (Anurag) played with Maushmi Chatterjee, Shakti Samant played with his plots and scripts. 

Or Amar Prem where he went against the grain and portrayed the delicate story of a courtesan and a lover never destined to be together.

Even in Kati Patang, he took Asha Parekh known for her glamours image , and made her wear just one saree throughout the film in a deglam role.

It was Amar Prem which gave Rajesh Khanna one of his most popular dialogues – Pushpa, I hate tears.

One of the lesser talked about films is Pagla kahin ka where Shammi Kapoor plays the role of a person with mental health issues- a movie with darker shades.

From a failed singer to director

Having started his career as an assistant director, Shakti Samanta made a few films like Bahu, Inspector before hitting the jackpot with Howrah Bridge in 1958. 

And then came the Shammi-Shakti combination with China Town, Kashmir ki Kali, An Evening in Paris and Pagla Kahin Ka.

For someone who came to the film industry to be an actor and singer, Shakti Samanta’s movies boasted of great music and he himself used to play the flute.

Master of the songs – Sapno ki Rani to Kuch to log kahenge

 There is a song for every mood and occasion in his films.

Kuch toh log kahenge by Anand Bakshi is the perfect antidote to situations we face when we feel overwhelmed by how the world judge will as. The joyful expression of love in Mere Sapno ki Rani.

Or the praise of your beloved’s beauty- Taarif Karoon kya uski or the heartbreak song from Amanush- Dil aisa kisi ne mera toda. Who can forget the sensuous Madhubala crooning Aaiye Meharban ?

From Train Tops to Helicopters

His song picturizations were amongst one of the best and unique.

I always liked the use of locations in his films. Amongst the first few to showcase the beauty of Kashmir was Shakti Samant.

Long before Chaiya Chaiya, we saw Rajesh Khanna and Zeenat Aman in a whole song on top of a train in Hum Dono Premi in Ajnabee. And Roop tera mastana is a single take song.

In the song Aasman Se Aaya Farishta from An Evening in Paris, Shammi Kapoor’s is shown singing while hanging from a helicopter! 

The meaning of a train journey was altered forever when Shakti Samanta showed a young Rajesh Khanna in a jeep running parallel to a train through the hills, and Sharmila Tagore reading a book, sitting on a window seat.

However, it was not just songs, it was the story, the characterization and the ability to sometimes go beyond the mainstream without losing the masses, that differentiated Shakti Samanta.

Amitabh- Shakti Samant

He was one director who knew how to mould literature into a film.

Bibhutibhushan Bandyopadhyay’s story Hinger Kochuri was turned into Amar Prem though it had been made in Bangla before. 

The Great Gambler was based on Vikramaditya’s Bengali novel Great Gambler whereas Barsaat ki ek raat was based on Shaktipada Rajguru’s novel- both films with Amitabh Bachchan. Barsaat ki ek raat was made in Bangla too with Amitabh in the main role.

He even made an India-Bangladesh joint venture film Aar Par with Mithun, Utpal Dutt and Bangladeshi actor Rozina.

Filmfare awards

Coming back to his roots, in a way it was SD Burman and Ashok Kumar who gave Hindi film industry a director like Shakti Samanta.

In the early days of his career, he used to go to SD Burman who told him clearly that his voice is not enough to be singer and should try something else. It was Ashok Kumar who encouraged Shakti Samanta to try his skills behind the scenes.

And finally, Shakti Samanta did try his hand in direction, and launched his banner Shakti films.

And went on to work with SD Burman’s son RD Burman on many unforgettable films including Amar Prem, Mehbooba, Kati Patang, The Great Gambler and Barsaat ki ek raat.

Later , he formed a distribution company Shakti-Raj with Rajesh Khanna.

He received Filmfare Award for Best Film for Aradhana, Amanush and Anurag.

Though the song is usually associated with the singers Rafi and Lata Mangeskhar, but it is equally apt for the director who gave this song- Tum mujhe yu bhula na paoge.

Ikkis: Reminding us of the Amitabh-Dharmendra magic via Agastya

In a scene from director Shriram Raghavan film Ikkis, Dharmendra, playing the role of a father, remembers his soldier son Arun and says—“मेरा बड़ा बेटा अरुण हमेशा 21 का रहेगा”

Ikkis is Agastya Nanda’s first theatrical release. Agastya’s father is played by Dharmendra—and this is his last film. The first film of one actor and the last film of another—this is a strange coincidence.

At an event related to Ikkis, remembering Dharmendra, Agastya said, “This is an emotional moment for me, because Dharm ji has worked with many generations of my family. Worked with my great grandfather, my grandfather. It has been no less than an honor for me to work with him.”

Here, Agastya was referring to his great-grandfather Raj Kapoor, in whose film Mera Naam Joker Dharmendra had worked. And the on-screen pairing of Agastya’s maternal grandfather Amitabh Bachchan and Dharmendra has been truly unmatched.


Dharmendra–Amitabh: a friendship that became immortal on screen

Audiences perhaps saw Amitabh and Dharmendra together on screen for the first time in Hrishikesh Mukherjee’s film Chupke Chupke, which was released on 11 April 1975, a few months before Sholay.

Dharmendra had already established himself as a major star. Zanjeer (1973) and Deewar (1975) had turned Amitabh Bachchan into the “angry young man.”

But Chupke Chupke was very different from all their other films.

Through this film, both actors showed that they were versatile performers, with as much control over comedy as over action.

Dharmendra, who became the fake driver Pyare Mohan from botany professor Parimal Tripathi, and Amitabh, who turned from an English professor into a fake botany professor—

Their comic rhythm matched so perfectly that where one left off, the other picked it up seamlessly.

The problem is that English professor Amitabh Bachchan falls in love with Jaya Bhaduri (Vasudha), who believes him to be the married Botany professor Parimal. And rejects his advances.

Annoyed by his inability to confess his love, Amitabh Bachchan says—

“मैं वसुधा (जया भादुड़ी) को पढ़ाने जाता हूँ मैं बन के नहीं तुम (धर्मेंद्र) बनके. तुम बनके जो कहता हूँ वो समझती हैं मैं कह रहा हूँ. कहता मैं ही हूँ ..लेकिन वो मैं जो तुम हो और जो तुम हो वो मैं हूँ….”

The real comic punch of this dialogue can only be felt by watching Dharmendra and Amitabh perform it—it cannot be experienced by merely reading it.


Ye Dosti Hum Nahin Chhodenge…

The magic of this film of Jai and Veeru, released 50 years ago, is that it was re-released on the big screen even in 2025.

Even after 50 years, when Gen Z creates reels on friendship, the song “Ye dosti hum nahin chhodenge” plays in the background.

In Sholay, Dharmendra and Amitabh showcased action, romance, tragedy, action—everything together.

Their timing with each other was such that they elevated one another’s performances.  Not sure whether it stemmed from two actors very much confident in their abilities. Or from their mutual respect for each other. Or respect for the craft. or the skills of the person directing them.

When Veeru delivered a dialogue, Jai completed it—nothing less, nothing more. Among the many strengths of Sholay, this too was one.

In the tank scene, when Dharmendra climbs the water tank and pretends to attempt suicide, there is chaos among the villagers, but Jai calmly sips tea and says, “कुछ नहीं हुआ. जब दारू उतरेगी तो ये भी उतर आएगा.”

Only Jai understands Veeru down to the last nerve.

Or in the final scene where Jai (Amitabh) is dying and says—
“मेरा खेल ख़त्म हो गया वीरू. जीए तो दोस्त के साथ, मरे तो दोस्त के साथ….”

There are very few films where the story of two friends makes you laugh and cry in this way.


Ram–Balram

In 1980, Amitabh and Dharmendra came together again in Ram Balram. Two brothers—one a thief, one a policeman—and a cruel relative who raises them.

A red car emerging through a massive pipe, a car running without a driver, and Dharmendra and Amitabh singing— “इक रस्ता दो राही, एक चोर एक सिपाही.”

Ram Balram is quite underwhelming though one can catch glimpses of the chemistry between the two that was the soul of Sholay.

For instance, when Dharmendra brings Zeenat Aman to the police station so that police sub-inspector Amitabh can put his stamp of approval on the relationship.

Since Dharmendra cannot reveal that Amitabh is his brother or why he has come to the station, the two speak in coded language in front of everyone. This scene could only be executed on screen through mutual comic timing.

Dharmendra—
“मैंने सोचा उस चोर की रिपोर्ट करवा दूँ जो मेरा सब कुछ चुरा कर ले गया. मेरे केस में कुछ दम नज़र आया आपको.”

Amitabh—
“हाँ केस की सूरत तो अच्छी है.”


Hum Kaun Hain

After 1980, the two appeared together in small roles in the 2004 thriller Hum Kaun Hain. Amitabh played Frank, and Dharmendra played his friend Virendra Veeru.

In one scene, Amitabh meets Dharmendra and says—
“मैं वहम की बात नहीं कर रहा, मैं हक़ीकत की बात कर रहा हूँ वीरू.”

The film does remind one of Jai and Veeru, but it did not give the two actors the space they needed.

When I had gone to England’s Yorkshire to cover the IIFA Awards, while presenting Dharmendra with the Lifetime Achievement Award, Amitabh Bachchan had said in his speech— “We have a secret. If Dharam ji had not recommended my name, I would not have been able to work in Sholay. It was only because of Dharam ji repeatedly insisting that Ramesh Sippy took me.”

In return, Dharmendra has always said—
“अमित मेरा बहुत प्यारा भाई है…”

And don’t forget the famous song Jon Jani Janaradhan where you see a dashing Dharmendra appear as film with Amitabh playing the waiter . What fun !

The Dharmendra–Amitabh pairing will never be seen on screen again.

Though audiences will see Dharmendra on the big screen one last time, that too with Agastya, from the next generation of Amitabh Bachchan’s clan.  But Amitabh-Dharmendra Jodi sab par ekkis padti thi.

And guess what, Ikkis will see Asrani, the angrezon ke zamane ka jailor with Dharam ji.

2025: Some of the best films- Homebound to Dhadak to Lokah

Most movies ( a lot ) are I saw this year was from the past- 50s to 90s- as if stuck in the past.

Hardly saw any movie in theatre, failing to step out , unless necessary. ( bad bad ).

Anyways,  from the selective movies I saw this year, here’s what caught my eye for various reasons 

Homebound : Enough said.  The movie makes you take a backseat, look at your privileges and of course the soul crushing most painful period of Corona lockdown. Tale of friendship, Tale of empathy with a rare gender less.

Lokah – Chapter 1 Chandra: Who thought we would get a Superwoman movie of our own, mired in our own folk traditions,  who is smart and can take on the world. This Malayalam movie is fun, great narrative, visual storytelling without tyring hard to please people  

The Mehta Boys:  Estranged parent-child relationship. May not be talked about, but very familiar. Boman Irani shines as the distant father , struggling to form a bond with his son ( Avinash Tiwary). Beautiful, poignant, cathartic as the two rediscover each other.  Brilliant directorial debut by Boman Irani.

Sitaare Zameen Par:  May not have soared to the heights of Tare Zameen Par. But one movie did enough to entertain and create sensitivity around specially abled children . Spirited young bunch who laugh, mock, loose , win and teach you a lesson in life.

Stolen:  This survival thriller film by Karan Tejpal in Hindi as much about child trafficking, illegal surrogacy as it is about unhealed emotional wounds. Shubham Vardan and Abhishek Banerjee as the two brother going to attend their mother’s wedding when they get entrapped with the saga of a stolen child.

Bison Kaalamaadan – How to make a sports drama that is not divorced from the social/ economic realities of its time. This Tamil film by Mari Selvaraj is a raw, physical and emotional depiction of the struggles of a Kabaddi player who fights community violence, caste oppression, state apathy to represent India.  I must confess I had never seen any movie by actor Dhruv Vikram. It is said to be  inspired by the life of Kabaddi player M. Ganesan

Humans In The Loop: This one astonished me , like when something totally unexpected strikes you. A single woman , from the tribal area, comes to work in a AI lab.  Her wisdom, learnt through daily grind in her village, clashes with what AI’s biased algorithm throws up.  Makes you think about AI differently. The most beautiful part is how her relationship with her teenaged daughter evolves over the time- from anger, to disdain, to acceptance

Dhadak 2 : The original Tamil film is much more raw , layered and intense. But none the less, Dhadak 2 raises the pertinent questions about caste , with the female lead getting  a voice of her own 

The Girlfriend :  An inclusive film firmly told from a female gaze. A college going simple girl, emotionally trained to always take care of others. A charming college boy, brought up in patriarchal mindset and imbibing the same values. The two meet, fall in love. But what happens when their worlds collide ? The Rahul Ravindran film is a good watch with Rashmika Mandana getting to do what she does best and not just lurk in the background.

Saiyaara :  Caught the pulse of the youth. Decent watch. 

Jugnuma : How refreshing is to have movie made not just in cities or glorified villages but in the hills and hamlets. This Manoj Bajpayee starrer is based int the hill of Uttarakhand. It is about nature with caste and supernatural forces weaved in.

Su from So ( Kannada):  You may go expecting not much, the premise is absurd,  spirit of a woman taking over a young man in a village. Chaos follows, Guruji is called. The film is not only a satire on such acts but in the comeday cum drama lies a deep message – how women’s stories are often untold. Hard to come across this genre. This premise is absurd from start to finish yet deep.

Other mentions : The Bad girls , The Great Shamsuddin family, Sister Midnight

Agra  and Sabar Bonda: Wish had the chance to see this one.  There were hardly any shows for Agra to watch in evening hours 

Dhurandhar – Not seen yet. Kantara – Half finished

Of course, there any many I haven’t watched from the best

2025: Harmanpreet’s Hug, Muskan’s Crown, Banu Mushtaq’s Booker — Not Just Victories, but a Fistful of Hope for Indian Women

A 36-year-old daughter, in what is perhaps the biggest moment of her life, celebrating a World Cup victory – runs to the boundary line and runs straight into her father’s arms.

And then, like a little child, she is lifted and held by her father the way parents do when their children are young.

When the Indian women’s cricket team won the World Cup on 4 November 2025, this moment wasn’t special only because the trophy had been won.

It was special because such open affection, love, and celebration between a father and daughter on a sports field has hardly been visible in Indian society.

When a father hugging his daughter became a statement

For Gen Z, this may seem perfectly normal. But traditionally, in a society where fathers either do not show their emotions — or are not allowed to by social conditioning — these images of Indian women spoke volumes.

Amid all this, quietly but with mountain-like strength, there stood a single mother in a village in Himachal Pradesh who raised her daughter alone. Her daughter, Renuka, went on to conquer the World Cup field.


Muskan’s Crowning Glory

And Away from the glamour of sport, in the small town of Rishikesh, 23-year-old Muskan achieved something similar in 2025. All she had was her talent and her courage.

On 4 November, when Indian women cricketers were playing the World Cup final, exactly one month earlier — on 4 October — Muskan was rehearsing with other girls for the Miss Rishikesh pageant.

In a video that went viral, a district-level leader of a local organisation is seen objecting to the skirts and western outfits worn by Muskan and other contestants. He says,
“Modeling is over. Go back home. This is against Uttarakhand’s culture.”

It was Muskan who responded: “Then why don’t you shut down the shops that sell these clothes? There are cigarette and liquor shops outside — close them first. Then I’ll stop wearing these clothes. If you have the right to your choice, so do we. Our opinions matter just as much as yours.”

Muskan stood alone at first, but very quickly other contestants and the organisers stood with her. The hotel manager asked the protesters to leave.

Muskan eventually became Miss Rishikesh, and the crown sat on her head. That day she didn’t just carry  a crown but a billion hopes as well.


Miss Universe Afterwards, Sisterhood First

This is not just the story of one Indian woman. Far away from India, something remarkable happened in Thailand in 2025 as well.

At an event before the Miss Universe pageant, several contestants walked out.Why? Because a Thai official publicly insulted Miss Mexico.

When Fatima Bosch objected, the official called security and threatened to disqualify contestants who supported Miss Mexico.

Despite this, Fatima and several other Miss Universe contestants walked out.

Isn’t it strange, really, that the word we commonly use for solidarity — bhaichara (brotherhood )— is also shaped through a male lens. If you wish, you can call this Miss Universe incident as behanchara- isterhood.


When an Actress Threw Her Weight Around

Even when it is about fighting alone, women are learning that too.

This year, when Tamil actress Gauri attended a press conference for her film Others, a male YouTuber asked the film’s hero whether it was difficult to lift Gauri in a scene because of her weight.

Instead of ignoring the question or staying silent, Gauri responded:

“What does my weight have to do with you? How is this connected to the film? My weight is my choice. It does not define my talent. Stop normalising body shaming. I don’t need your validation.”

What was surprising was that when an argument broke out between the journalist and Gauri, the only person standing with Gauri was Gauri herself.

Over the years , the questions haven’t changed much. But the women answering them have. Gauri’s response carried such weight that the journalist later had to apologise.


Banu Mushtaq: The Voice of Countless Other Women

2025 was the year when both ordinary and extraordinary women not only raised their own voices but became voices for other women too.

Indian writer Banu Mushtaq won the International Booker Prize in 2025 for her book Heart Lamp.

Her own life has passed through many difficult stages. In an interview with Vogue, she said: “After my love marriage, I was suddenly told to wear a burqa and devote my entire life to household work. At the age of 29, I became a mother suffering from postpartum depression.”

But one act of resistance changed her life.

Heart Lamp is a book in which, through 12 stories written between 1990 and 2023, Banu Mushtaq gives voice to the struggles, confusions, and emotions of Muslim women in South India.

By 2025, the fictional women in Banu Mushtaq’s stories found echoes of real-life voices — Harmanpreet, Jemimah, Muskan, and Gauri.

And as ad guru Piyush Pandey once said:
“Mile Sur Mera Tumhara To sur bane hamara.”

Dharmendra : Remembering Through Satyakam, a deeply disturbing moral yet important tale

Dharmendra, the much-loved film star, would have turned 90 on 8 Dec 2025. It is also Sharmila Tagore’s birthday.

Just the time to revisit one of his earlier, less successful, but one of the most acclaimed films – Satyakam.

My First Encounter with Satyakam: A Film That Leaves You Uneasy

I still remember when I watched Satyakam for the first time. It left me so uneasy, so perplexed and uncomfortable with the moral dilemmas it raised. I have rarely felt so after watching a movie.

On one hand I stood with what the character of Dharmendra stood for – for truth and honesty – come what may. And at the same time,

I was almost angry with what he put his family through who pays the cost of his hyper idealism. And he himself ultimately dies – with his idealism intact. But did he actually win?

Satyapriya’s India: Hope, Innocence and the Dream of a New Nation

The story is of a young man in college in 1946, pre independent India. The budding engineer is full of idealism to serve his nation, which was at the cusp of Independence. Says a naive Dharmendra

Hum Sach much kitne bhagyawan hain.
Kitne acche dinon main janam liya hai. Bhookh berozgari black marketing sab khatam ho jayegi. Sach poocho to mehnat aur imandari ke din ab aayein hain.
Soch kar hi aason aa jate hain
e Satyapriya (Dharmendra) –

(We are truly so fortunate. We were born in such good times. Hunger, unemployment, and black marketing will all come to an end. The time for hard work and honesty has finally arrived. Just thinking about it brings tears to my eyes.)

When Idealism Meets Reality: Corruption, Compromise and Disillusionment

But what he confronts him after he starts working as an Engineer is an India where bribes are paid, anomalies are ignored, projects with poor quality are passed. But he will not take it. And hence he gets transferred every few months or resigns.

He is relentless… even in things like not allowing the poor labourers to use government tools to perform their rituals around Vishwakarma pooja.


He throws out a man for taking bribe. The poor man’s wife confronts him how their child is dying without medicines. He takes back the termination letter. But someone has to pay the price of a corrupt system, so he resigns.

Punishing himself and his family.

The Unraveling of a Man: Dharmendra’s Powerful Transformation

The transformation of a happy, handsome young man to this angry, frustrated young man is superbly played by Dharmendra.

In a brilliant foil to the hyper idealistic Satya is his college friend and confidant Naren – a superb Sanjeev Kumar. He is not corrupt but realistic.

When Sanjeev Kumar confronts Dharmendra, he says

“Aazadi se pehle hum kya kya sapne dekhte the. Tab to ye naaz tha hum angrez ke saath lad rahein hain lekin ab to hum ek doorse ke saath ladne lage hain.Aajkal to aisa lagta hai ki hum burai mein ek doosre ka muqabla karne lage hain. Humare ird gird har cheez sadti ja raji hai. Na kisi ka dharam raha na imaan. Mera to ji chahta hai ki haath mein chabuk le loon dayein bayein sabki khaal udedh doon.”

( “Before Independence, we felt proud that we were fighting the British — but now we have started fighting among ourselves.These days it feels as if we are competing with each other in wrongdoing)

In fact, the story of the film is narrated by Sanjeev Kumar and starts with a quote of Mahatma Gandhi.

Ranjana’s Pain, Strength and Quiet Dignity: Sharmila Tagore’s Finest Moments

However, some of the best moments of the film for me are the scenes with Sharmila Tagore. A young girl, daughter of a prostitute, who is forced to live  an undignified life in a Princely house

Satyapriya has been brought up in an orthodox gurukul by his grandfather (Ashok Kumar) who follows chaste principals.


When Satyapriya comes face to face with Ranjana (Sharmila), both develop a trust and a bond, without putting it in words.

For the first time, Sharmila Tagore feels valued but understands her boundaries. One night she begs Dharmendra to take her with him to the city where she will work as a maid.


But Rajana’s illicit father forcibly takes her away and she is raped by the prince. Dharmendra lacks the courage to marry someone like Sharmila.

 But later feels guilty and he comes back to marry Ranjana and gives his name to the child.However, years pass by, but something is missing between the two. There is support, and respect but no intimacy.

The Shattering Confrontation: When Sharmila Speaks Her Truth

And it is then, in a brilliant scene, Sharmila quietly confronts Dharmendra, words that pierce through your soul. Watch this conversation between the two


Sharmila- Jab bhi tum mere kareeb aaye, mujhe bahon mein lena chaha, to kaun aaata hai hum dono ke beech mein? Kya main nahin samsjhti hoon wo kya hai? Main to pichli zindgi ko bhoolna chahti hoon lekin…

( Whenever you come to come closer to me,  you think I don’t know what comes inbetween us ?)


Dharmendra: Ye sab baatein jane do. Tum janti ho main tumse pyar karta hoon.


Sharmila : Bas, aur kuch Nahin chahiye ? Isliye to Ji chahta hai apne aap to khatam kar doon. Phir ek naya jamam, naya shaeer, nayi aatma lekar aaon tumhare paas.

( I wish I could finish myself and be reborn and come back to you.)


Even though Satyapriya is upright about his principals in professional life but in personal life, despite love, he has not been able to shake off his orthodox upbringing and really let go of his wife’s past.

The beauty of Satyakam is that despite being Dharmendra’s film, a film centred around a male lead, it has a female gaze which can be so rare to see in films.

A Rare Female Gaze in a Male-Centred Story

Despite the sufferings, Sharmila dutifully stays with Satyapriya – because she loves him and because she has no choice – may be.

Quietly, she puts up with his idiosyncrasies.

Like when she tells Sanjeev Kumar – Ab to ye radio ke saath bhi jhagda karne lage. Jab radio pe koi kehta hai falane plan ke liye itne crore rupaiye manzoor hue, to ye bolne lagte hain ab itne mein se kitne crore kiski pocket mein jayenge. Radio apni bakbak kiye jata hai aur ye apni. ( He was started arguing even with a Radio now).

In a heart breaking scene, lying on death bed, Dharmedra signs a pending bill of a contractor which he had refused to do for months on grounds of morality. He wants his wife and children not to be at anyone’s mercy.

But Sharmila, though broken, tears the papers, putting faith in Satyapriya and his principals.

The Final Reckoning: Truth, Courage and Acceptance

In the end, when Dharmendra dies, the grandfather (Ashok Kumar) comes and denies the rights to perform the funeral to Dharmendra’s son. He lies – Abhi bahut Chhota hai na.


But the child (Sarika) says, He is lying. He doesn’t want us to come because I am not my fathers’s son. My mother told me everything.


Shocked by how bravely, a ‘fallen woman’ dares to say the truth which he has hidden for years, he repents and accepts both of them saying – Satya bolne ka ahankar nahin sahas chahiye.( To say the truth, you need courage but truthful arrogance)  .. A bitter truth.

Hrishikesh Mukherjee’s Craft: Form, Landscape and Dialogues

Hrishikesh Mukherjee experiments both with form and content in this movie – see the first and last scenes when Dharmendra is in hospital and how the camera pans to nothingness.

Jaywant Pathare uses the local landscapes brilliantly as cinematographer.

Rajinder Singh Bedi, the master, has written the dialogues. Music wasn’t really the high point of the movie. The movie won a National award.

Why Satyakam Still Matters: A Slow, Simmering Moral Dilemma

The movie is made at its own pace, it doesn’t rush through, it is slow. It simmers and by the end it leaves you morally conflicted. A dilemma you carry for a long time.

A film that you might feel is still relevant with this dialogue –  Aajkal to aisa lagta hai ki hum burai mein ek doosre ka muqabla karne lage hain.